BG | EN

Appeals to the bitter end: how Dryanovo and dozens of municipalities fell into a legal trap under the public procurement act

“In this residential cooperative, they have been waiting for two years for the renovation of the building to begin.”
Photo: “For the Truth.”

NSK Sofia, which has blocked the renovation of an apartment building in Dryanovo for the second time, has appealed 35 public procurement contracts in various Bulgarian municipalities in 2025 alone. The data available on the public portal of the Commission for Protection of Competition (CPC) outlines a consistent pattern whereby almost every procedure in which the company is not ranked first is challenged.

A telling example of the consequences of this pattern is Dryanovo, where for the second year in a row the owners of an apartment building on Shipka Street have been waiting for their building to be renovated with approved funding under the National Recovery and Sustainability Plan. However, the procedure for selecting a contractor has been suspended for the second time following a complaint by NSK Sofia, which was removed from the commission appointed by the mayor in December last year. However, the procedure for selecting a contractor has been suspended for the second time following a complaint by NSK Sofia, which was removed from the commission appointed by Mayor Trifon Panchev for the second time in December last year.

Appealing to the bitter end is permitted by law

The right to appeal in procedures under the Public Procurement Act (PPA) is guaranteed. It is a safeguard against arbitrariness on the part of contracting authorities and protects the equality of participants, the legality of procedures, and the public interest, as public resources, i.e., taxpayers’ money, are being spent. Therefore, all procedures under the PPL are public and transparent in order to eliminate any suspicion of bias on the part of contracting authorities and contractors. It is a separate issue that in many cases these guarantees exist only on paper, but in any case, the legislation has provided for public control through transparency in the selection of contractors.

However, this right is not absolute. Bulgarian and European law apply the general principle that every right should be exercised in good faith and in accordance with its purpose. However, when the right of appeal causes delays, as in Dryanovo, and when preparing this text it turned out that the situation is repeated in dozens of other municipalities, the implementation of a project is blocked and doubts arise as to the real purpose of the appeal.

The same omissions

A check by Za Istinata shows that the company that is halting the implementation of an energy renovation project for a multi-family residential building at 143 Shipka Street in Dryanovo due to an appeal has been systematically removed from the contractor selection procedures because of omissions in its technical proposal. In almost all 35 procedures in 2025 and in a total of over fifty in the last five years in which NSK Sofia has been removed from participation, it is because of omissions in the technical proposal. In almost all 35 procedures in 2025 and in a total of over fifty in the last five years in which NSK Sofia has been excluded from participation, it is because of omissions in the technical proposal, most often in the organization of the implementation of the activities.

Frozen projects and millions of uninvested leva

The findings of the commission in the municipality of Harmanli, for example, are completely identical, where NSK Sofia appealed the ranking in seven public procurement procedures, all for the introduction of energy efficiency measures in residential buildings. The seven appeals were filed in October 2025, and public hearings of the CPC are scheduled for January 15 this year, but no decisions have been made on them as of the publication of this text. At the same time, the municipality of Harmanli cannot award the renovation contract until a final decision on the appeal has been made, and the final say rests with the Supreme Administrative Court, if, of course, the case goes to court.

The same company has appealed four procedures in Nova Zagora, the same number in Varna and Sofia, two in Pleven, and one each in Gurkovo, Polski Trambesh, Razgrad, Pazardzhik, and elsewhere. Projects are waiting to be implemented, millions of leva are sitting in accounts waiting to be invested, and dozens of households are hoping for renovated homes.

In a small number of appeals, the CPC has ruled in favor of NSK Sofia, but there are also cases where it has ruled against it. In 2025, the municipalities of Elhovo and Targovishte lost lawsuits filed against their mayors’ decisions to select contractors for public procurement, and in 2024, a decision by the municipality of Dve Mogili was also ruled unlawful. However, in the majority of the proceedings concluded before the CPC, NSK Sofia’s complaints were dismissed.

Exercising its right to judicial protection, the company appealed the CPC’s decisions before the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC), and the situation was reversed—in the majority of its decisions, the SAC overturned the CPC’s rulings and returned the proceedings to the respective municipality. With this, justice should have prevailed, but what happened in Dryanovo?

From a lack of grounds to 76 pages of grounds

After the Supreme Administrative Court returned the ranking of the public procurement for the renovation of an apartment building in the town for reconsideration in the autumn of last year, the municipality commissioned a re-examination of the bids submitted, as the court ruled that the protocol for ranking the participants did not contain specific findings and grounds, making it impossible to determine whether the bid evaluation committee had been able to compare them at all in order to select the most economically advantageous one.

The re-evaluation of the bids took place on December 3, 2025, and is justified in 76 pages. The result of this re-evaluation repeated the first ranking – the company proposed as the contractor, Kidat Group, was awarded the highest number of points, and the participant that had been eliminated the first time, NSK Sofia, was eliminated for a second time. Once again, it lodged a complaint with the CPC.

All this, in addition to the stress for citizens who are waiting for their building to be converted into an energy-efficient one, has cost taxpayers in Dryanovo BGN 4,700 so far in expenses that the Municipality of Dryanovo has to pay to the disqualified participant.

Citizens are the ones who suffer

Regardless of whether the complaints are justified or not, which is something that only the court can decide, the result of the endless appeals is that projects are blocked, public investments are delayed for years, and costs and losses accumulate. All of this harms citizens, who have no procedural means to respond. Or perhaps they do, because the patience of the residents of the apartment building on Shipka Street in Dryanovo has run out, and they are discussing the possibility of also seeking protection of their interests in court.

Meanwhile, another year is wasted waiting for the institutions to rule on the construction company’s appeals. No one can predict how it will all end, because the company can appeal indefinitely. Article 196, paragraph 1 of the Public Procurement Act regulates this right and there are no restrictions. The text reads: “Any decision of the contracting authorities in a public procurement procedure is subject to appeal.” So the contracting authority, in this case the Municipality of Dryanovo, is in a legal trap – it can neither start the project nor stop the appeals.

In such circumstances, the question undoubtedly arises as to whether, if a company exercises its indisputable right of appeal in dozens of procedures in different municipalities, the manner in which it does so is consistent with the purpose of that right.

Истината струва скъпо. Ако сте я открили тук – подкрепете ни!

Най-четени: Още за новините

Още от автора

There is no money for repairs, but Dryanovo is looking for a contractor to restore the Kolyu Ficheto bridge

Dryanovo Municipality has launched a procedure to select a contractor to carry out repairs and conservation-restoration works on Kolyu Ficheto’s bridge over the Dryanovska River. The estimated value...

The contractor enters the ruined apartments in Sevlievo after renovation under the PVU for repairs

The contractor responsible for the energy renovation of Block No. 1 in the Dimitаr Blagoev residential complex in Sevlievo will carry out interior repairs at its own expense...

Only small classes in one high school in Dryanovo – how the small enrollment becomes an argument for their preservation

The Dryanovo Municipal Council will have to give the green light to preserve six small classes for the 2026/2027 school year at the town’s two schools. The formal...

Още за новините

There is no money for repairs, but Dryanovo is looking for a contractor to restore the Kolyu Ficheto bridge

Dryanovo Municipality has launched a procedure to select a contractor to carry out repairs and conservation-restoration works on Kolyu Ficheto’s bridge over the Dryanovska River. The estimated value...

Almost every second contract of the Municipality of Nedelino is concluded with a single offer

With only one bid submitted, 66 out of a total of 147 public procurement contracts awarded by Nedelino Municipality between October 2020 and July 2026 were signed. Their...

Medical supervision found no violations in Silistra cardiology, but does not want private partners

Medical services in invasive cardiology worth just over €1 million in 2025 and €522,000 in the first half of 2026 were carried out under a joint activity agreement...