BG | EN

The mayor of Stara Zagora advances the interests of a large grain producer with a change in the city’s general development plan

Once again, the local government in Stara Zagora is disregarding the public interest in favor of private interests. At the proposal of Mayor Zivko Todorov, the Municipal Council voted in March of this year to change the General Development Plan of the city for two urbanized properties. Previously designated as green areas for public use – parks or gardens, their purpose is now set to change (if the decision comes into effect) to low-rise residential construction. An investigation by “Za istinata” (“For the Truth”) revealed that one of the parcel owners is Krasimira Hristova, the wife of Radislav Hristov – the chairman of the Union of Thracian Grain Producers in Bulgaria and a member of the board of the national sector union.

The Spatial Development Act regulates complex public relationships, as well as those who implement it. They must balance public and private interests, but they should be particularly cautious when it comes to preserving green spaces, as citizens are especially sensitive to this issue.

The local government in Stara Zagora likes to present the city almost as a green oasis in an urbanized area.

However, practice shows that the municipal council votes on amendments to the General Development Plan that allow for the removal of not just one or two hectares of forests and parks, which were afforested during the communist regime in the country. Among the latest examples is the saga of cutting down more than 70 trees, part of the park adjacent to the former party school in the “Tri Chuchura” neighborhood, now a private property of “Property Start” LLC. This also includes the decision to change the designation of 9 decares of forest in the lands of the village of Sulitza, which gives a “green light” to businessman and former officer of the now-defunct State Security (the repressive apparatus of the communist state) Ventsislav Draganov to pursue his investment plan for the construction of a holiday village.

At its March session, the Municipal Council in Stara Zagora voted on a decision to change the General Development Plan (GDP) for two land properties, each measuring 1 decare, in the area of “Bozhi Rid” within the lands of the village of Bogomilovo. They are located northwest of the Thracian University and in close proximity to the tennis courts of the family complex Jack, “charmingly nestled among a pine forest,” as stated in one advertisement.

Both properties are designated as forest areas, with a use designation of “other non-timber forest land,” according to the ownership documents and sketches of the land parcels issued by the Geodesy, Cartography, and Cadastre Office in Stara Zagora in 2023, when they were purchased. At the end of February last year, the municipal councilors gave preliminary consent for the change to the General Development Plan (GDP), but only after the proposal was re-voted—a common practice in the Municipal Council when the majority does not vote “correctly.”

In this specific case, Mayor Zivko Todorov, in violation of the Council’s rules of procedure, proposed the project for the change to the GDP for a third vote (without any change in circumstances) after it had been rejected twice before. Outside the chamber, municipal councilors shared that they had been pressured to support the decision to change the GDP. However, only Maria Dineva—the chairwoman of the previous council and now of the local coalition “Agrarian People’s Union”—stated during a meeting of the permanent commission on territorial and urban planning that a man she knows well, without naming him, called her to say that she would need to vote for the change to the GDP at the next session. After Dineva responded that she and her colleagues would not change their stance, she heard the retort on the phone: “Well, Boyko has voted for something and later changed his mind, so why wouldn’t you?”

Similar brazen insinuations were directed at me in a phone conversation with a public figure, whose name I will mention when the plot leads to him.

Decisions No. 1037 and 1038 from March 27 of this year were approved by the Stara Zagora Municipal Council with 32 votes for the first and 30 votes for the second. In cases like this, when the General Development Plan (GDP) is changed for urbanized areas where the properties are designated for landscaping, a qualified majority or the votes of 34 municipal councilors is required. And this is only in exceptionally rare cases listed in the Spatial Development Act. Obviously, the lawyers of the Stara Zagora Municipality hold a different opinion—whether due to incompetence or fully conscious awareness is known only to them and their superiors. In a comment to “For the Truth,” experts stated that the mentioned properties are in an urbanized area. Supporting their claim is the fact that a public discussion was held for the change to the GDP for these properties, which the law does not require in other cases.

In the proposals from Mayor Todorov to the municipal councilors for the approval of the amendment to the General Development Plan, it is indicated that in the previous GDP from 2011, the two land parcels were designated as a residential area with low-rise and free-standing primary construction. In the new GDP, approved and activated in 2022, this designated area is planned for landscaped areas for public use. This, according to the proposer of the amendment, Zivko Todorov, renders the properties practically unusable and contradicts the investment intentions of the contractor to change their designation due to serious changes in socio-economic conditions (according to Article 134, Paragraph 1, Item 1 of the Spatial Development Act).

However, in practice, such changes do not exist, and referencing this regulation in the Spatial Development Act is strange, but municipal councilors comment that the administration uses it with every submission of a proposal for changing the GDP of Stara Zagora.

The second argument of Mayor Todorov, and indeed in every similar case, is that the investment intentions of property owners should not be hindered when they request a change in the designation of their properties. However, the new GDP took effect in 2022, while the properties in question were acquired in 2023. The buyers were well aware that they were purchasing forests, protected by law and designated for landscaping.

But obviously, following a promise from the higher echelons of the municipal administration that the designation of the properties could be changed, the contractors are submitting projects to amend the GDP in order to align the designated zone and development parameters of their properties with those of neighboring ones, which have been designated as a residential area. In fact, only one neighboring property’s designation was changed, and that was before the new GDP from 2022 came into effect. The mayor, who is the proposer of the amendment in the Municipal Council, refers to an opinion from the Regional Directorate of Forests – Stara Zagora, agreeing to the project for amending the General Development Plan, which states that “the investment intention will not affect the implementation of forestry and hunting activities.”

In a statement to “Za istinata” (“For the Truth”) the Regional Directorate of Forests explained that, according to the Forest Law (Article 163), projects for amending the General Development Plan (GDP) must be coordinated through their territorial divisions – the forestry and hunting enterprises. A forestry plan from 2016 states that the area in question (planted with coniferous trees over half a century ago) is in poor condition.

Nine years later, the forest is alive and visibly does not look bad, although this is merely an opinion at first glance.

The proposal from the proposer indicates that the property owners submitted project documentation along with opinions and conclusions from the Regional Inspectorate of Environment and Waters (RIEW), the Regional Health Inspectorate (RHI), the Basin Directorate, the electric supply company EVN, and the water supply and sewage company, as well as minutes from the public discussion of the proposal to change the GDP and from the decision of the Expert Council for Territorial Planning (ECTP).

However, these documents were not provided to the councilors, so they could make an informed decision (with the exception of the ECTP opinion), nor were they published on the municipal website.

The “Revival” group in the Municipal Council has notified the regional governor of Stara Zagora about the illegal decision regarding the change to the GDP. The reasons can be read here (Word document). Among the most important is the lack of the above-mentioned opinions, conclusions, and decisions from the relevant institutions, as well as the fact that no documents were attached to the announcement for the public discussion and that the councilors were not provided with the minutes from it.

Announcement for a public discussion on a project for a partial amendment to the General Development Plan of Stara Zagora Municipality – Parcel 04738.90.40, land of the village of Bogomilovo | Stara Zagora Municipality ↗

In their notification, the councilors from the party of Kostadin Kostadinov indicate that the proposals to change the GDP of Stara Zagora had already been rejected by decisions of the Municipal Council on October 31 and December 18 of last year, and were resubmitted for a third time without any changes in the relevant circumstances. These actions, they argue, grossly violate the Rules of Procedure for the Organization and Activities of the Municipal Council, specifically the conditions of Article 36(3), according to which “Submitted projects for the adoption of acts of the council that have been rejected cannot be resubmitted if they have the same or similar subject, except in the event of a change in specific circumstances.”

Aristotle said long ago that the law should govern, and that law is order, and a good law is good order.

Frequently, we explain every disorder in the state by citing bad laws. Whether the Spatial Development Act (ZUT) is good or bad, having been amended more than 120 times, legal experts and specialists can say. But there is no doubt that in this case we are examining, this law has been trampled on, and this is not a precedent in the work of the Stara Zagora Municipal Council. Because often the majority votes on decisions not in favor of all but only for certain citizens, whose rights prove to be prioritized and more important than the rights of others.

In this case, it is evident that the Mayor of Stara Zagora is lobbying for the interests of Radislav Hristov, or more specifically, for the interests of his wife, which amounts to the same thing. Otherwise, he would not be so insistent on pushing through the change in the designation of the properties in the General Development Plan at any cost.

How many of the trees in these properties will be cut down will become clear after the detailed development plan (PUP) is created. In a telephone conversation with Radislav Hristov yesterday, he confirmed to “For the Truth” that he is the husband of Krasimira Hristova—the owner of one of the properties. Minutes later, he called to say…

“I know you and I know what you will write… I will decide whether to sue you.”

Visibly annoyed, he asked why I thought he would cut down the forest. In fact, he wanted to build a kindergarten there, but he immediately added that tomorrow, when he wakes up, he might think of another idea. What ideas Radislav Hristov has for his wife’s property is of no interest to anyone. Furthermore, the request for a change in its designation clearly indicates it is for residential construction.

It was important to preserve the forest, but what does some public interest mean in this context?

Instead of continuously submitting proposals for changes to the General Development Plan (GDP), the Mayor of Stara Zagora should follow the guidelines from the regional ministry, as reflected in its position on processing amendments to the GDP of municipalities. It clearly states that “in order to provide conditions for sustainable development of the municipality’s territory, the procedure for amending the GDP should not be conducted for a separate private initiative, but for grouped cases on a common characteristic related to a specific necessity, while adhering to a balanced approach for the development of all types of territories covered by the GDP.”

The population in Stara Zagora continues to decline, unofficially falling below 100,000 residents. Despite this, the construction of new residential buildings continues, but those with financial means no longer want to live, as they once did, in the central parts of the city. Therefore, they are increasingly looking toward the outskirts, especially the areas bordering forests, where there is less traffic, the air is cleaner, and they can reside in single-family homes.

Meanwhile, the local government is doing everything in its power to assist in realizing these “investment intentions.”

Ordinary citizens are left with the right to contest the illegal decisions of the local government and to protest when that right is taken away from them. If anyone even cares…

“Za istinata” (“For the Truth”) attempted to seek opinions from the chairwoman of the Municipal Council, Iveta Lazarova, from Mayor Zivko Todorov, and from the relevant deputy mayor, architect Martin Paskalev, but was unable to establish contact with any of them.

Истината струва скъпо. Ако сте я открили тук – подкрепете ни!

Най-четени разследвания

Още от автора

550 Roma houses demolished in 15 years in Stara Zagora – the law has been implemented, the people have been forgotten (video)

In the third year of his fourth term as mayor of Stara Zagora, Zhivko Todorov, a former member of GERB’s Executive Commission, demolished the last 20 illegal houses...

The local government in Stara Zagora will make dozens more Roma families with young children homeless without caring for their future

On Monday, 27 July, Stara Zagora was due to carry out the forced demolition of illegal Roma houses in the Lozenets neighbourhood – the last such homes in...

The Regional Ministry is delaying payments for completely unnecessary repairs to two city parks in Stara Zagora

Projects to renovate two parks in the central part of Stara Zagora – “5 October” and “Alexander Stamboliyski” – should have been completed long ago, as both were...

Още разследвания

Public procurement in Nedelino awarded to small firm, despite lack of competition

A nearly 1.7 million BGN (excluding VAT) public tender for the reconstruction and rehabilitation of the main street "Alexander Stamboliyski" in Nedelino has been awarded to the small...

“Captured Energy”: An insider reveals how the secret holding “Orion” owned by Hristo Kovachki controls the market

"Energy in Bulgaria is captured. And the owner of this captured energy is called Hristo Kovachki." With these words, former gas trading director at "Orion Holding" Veselin Todorov...

“Save Bedechka” Association: A deal with municipal properties deprives Stara Zagora of more than 500 thousand leva

The Municipal Council of Stara Zagora approved the exchange of municipal properties for lands in "Bedekka" Park, owned by "Esteti Homes" EOOD, a company owned by Evgeni Lishev....