
The Commission on Academic Ethics at the Ministry of Education and Science has a new composition, learned “Za Istinata” from its sources. In a letter from early July this year, Minister Galin Tsokov requested the Rectors’ Council in Bulgaria, the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences (BAS), the sectoral trade unions in higher education and science under KNSB and KT “Podkrepa,” and the Union of Scientists to nominate no fewer than two qualified individuals from four scientific fields to fill the Commission (the letter can be viewed at the end of the text).
The previous members of the Commission on Academic Ethics (CAE) submitted a collective resignation following attempts to retaliate against them by Venelin Terziev, referred to as “Ostap Bender in science.”
This professor, who has been investigated multiple times for plagiarism across four universities, has filed lawsuits with private claims against each member of the Commission. In its report, the CAE confirmed a report of plagiarism against him, resulting in the revocation of his scientific degree of “Doctor of Sciences,” awarded by the National Military University “V. Lavski” in Veliko Tarnovo. The Ministry of Education and Science (MoES) appealed to the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) against a ruling by the Administrative Court in Ruse, which ruled in favor of Terziev, but the case was discontinued because the ministry failed to send the required documentation requested by the court twice. This gives the plagiarist grounds to pursue his colleagues, and they, abandoned by the ministry, refuse to participate in the CAE—a monitoring and advisory body for the Minister of Education and Science.
How Galin Tsokov conducted the selection of the new members of the Commission on Academic Ethics and whom he consulted remains unknown. It is interesting to note who nominated the professors from two higher education institutions in Plovdiv, Bozhidar Ivanov Hadzhiev and Lyubomir Ivanov Karadzhov. Colleagues see Terziev’s long reach behind their selection for the new composition of the Commission. However, what is even more important is what policy the Ministry of Education will adopt and whether it will continue to tolerate plagiarism through actions or inaction.
A professor from the Trakia University in Stara Zagora, whose consent to be quoted was not sought, stated in an unofficial conversation:
“Plagiarism is a taboo topic in our circles!” This is a peculiar acknowledgment of the heavy guilt felt within the Bulgarian academic community.
“Za Istinata” sent questions to the Minister of Education and Science under the Access to Public Information Act regarding plagiarism and received responses within the timeframe specified by the law.
They were requested after the media outlet began its own investigation into a plagiarism complaint filed by disciplinary dismissal associate professor Lazar Lazarov from Trakia University in Stara Zagora against his rector, Professor Dobri Yarkov. According to the decision from the Ministry of Education and Science (MoES), received without an outgoing number, it becomes clear that from the beginning of June last year until now—during the last period of management by Professor Galin Tsokov, who was Minister of Education and Science in the “Denkov” cabinet—54 notifications have been received by the ministry. Of these, 13 are related to plagiarism in scientific works submitted for evaluation in competitive procedures for obtaining a scientific degree and for occupying an academic position.
Two of the ongoing checks are linked to allegations of plagiarism against the rectors of two state universities in Bulgaria concerning the scientific works they submitted in competitions for the academic position of “professor.”
The ministry did not disclose their names, but it is a public secret that these are Professor Dimitar Dimitrov—the rector of UNSS—and Professor Dobri Yarkov—the rector of Trakia University in Stara Zagora. “Za Istinata” publicly announced facts related to the complaint against Professor Yarkov for the first time.
As a result of the completed checks during Professor Tsokov’s tenure as the caretaker Minister of Education and Science, the scientific degree of one individual accused of plagiarism and misrepresentation of scientific data was revoked, leading to their dismissal from the academic position of “professor.” Additionally, two awarded educational and scientific degrees of “doctor” were revoked from individuals found guilty of plagiarism in their submitted scientific works.
The decision from the Ministry of Education and Science (MoES) outlines in detail the procedure and timelines for checking reports of plagiarism as stipulated in the Academic Staff Development Act. The Commission on Academic Ethics is required to respond to each admissible report within 30 days with a report to the minister, based on the assessments of each of the three independent arbitrators. When asked if there have been cases where the Ethics Committee did not issue decisions on plagiarism reports and why, the ministry responded that “there are isolated cases where the CAE rightly did not issue a report within the specified time frame due to a lack of arbitrators or delays from higher education institutions/scientific organizations in presenting the required documentation for the procedures.”
The Academic Staff Development Act does not specify a concrete deadline for the preparation of expert opinions by the arbitrators, nor are sanctions provided for those who fail to present an opinion to the CAE, which further hinders the completion of the investigation regarding specific reports, the ministry clarifies in its decision.
Why is it Difficult to Find Independent Arbitrators?
The answer to this question largely explains why the battle against plagiarism seems doomed, at least to date.
The main reason many individuals who meet the criteria to be arbitrators refuse to accept is that no one wants “a healthy head – a disease,” meaning trouble. According to the law, the arbitrators must remain anonymous, and therefore are only designated by initials, although they can easily be recognized in any professional field. The individual accused of plagiarism should not know their names until the report from the Commission on Academic Ethics is released. However, in practice, the opposite seems to be true—the arbitrators not only do not remain anonymous, but immediately after being appointed by the Commission on Academic Ethics and designated by the minister, they become known to the individuals being investigated. Those individuals have ample time to take preemptive actions, such as offering bribes, making threats, or even filing reports against the arbitrators for plagiarism, which they attack using scientometrics, comments Professor Dr. Stoyko Stoykov, who filed plagiarism reports in 2021 with the MoES against Marin Georgiev, Daniela Vezieva (former Minister of Economy), Preslava Dimitrova, and Ekaterina Arabska—doctoral students of the thrice-accused professor of plagiarism, Venelin Terziev, against whom Stoykov also filed a report. He claims there are instances in which the individual accused of plagiarism provides ready opinions to the arbitrators, who merely sign them and submit them to the Commission on Academic Ethics.
According to other well-informed sources from the academic community, who wished to remain anonymous, information regarding the arbitrators is even sold by employees in the MoES.
To prevent the process of checking for plagiarism from being compromised, Professor Stoykov proposes creating a regulation for the selection of arbitrators and ensuring their protection. Meanwhile, Professor Dr. Miglena Temelkova—the rector of the University of Telecommunications and Posts and chair of the Rectors’ Council in Bulgaria—expressed her opinion that plagiarism should be proven through external international expertise, but it is unlikely anyone would be willing to undertake this for meager remuneration.
In this context, a logical question arises: who will agree to be an arbitrator for the plagiarism reports against the two rectors of state universities, one of whom—Professor Dobri Yarkov—was recently elected as the deputy chair of the Rectors’ Council in Bulgaria?
The the Ministry of Education and Science (MoES) disheartens the honest individuals in our academic circles who could potentially serve as arbitrators, with examples like that of Associate Professor Dr. Ekaterina Kyuskieva-Arabska—the rector of the private University for Agribusiness and Regional Development. With her, the list of rectors being investigated for plagiarism becomes three.
Anatoliy Asenov—one of the arbitrators in the investigation of the complaint against her, filed before she became rector—has not submitted a report to the Commission on Academic Ethics (CAE) for over a year and a half, unlike the other two, who confirm the plagiarism 100 percent. A new arbitrator was appointed, who submitted a report on May 26 this year with the same conclusions, claims Professor Stoykov. However, Galin Tsokov does not comply with the legal requirement to send the reports of the experts to the investigated Arabaka, who has the legal right to contest them—a fact that is not mentioned in the minister’s responses to “Za Istinata.”
As a result, the case remains “pending” and can only be resolved by the court, provided there is an interested party, according to the legal definition, willing to sue the minister.
Professor Stoykov is adamant that the Ministry of Education and Science (MoES) has worked to “break through” the procedure for proving plagiarism, effectively turning the oversight process into an unregulated one. He points to two bottlenecks in the investigation that must adhere to legal requirements—the rector (the head) of the higher education institution and the minister. The first is responsible for appealing, if applicable, the administrative court’s decision to revoke the scientific degree and declare the diploma invalid. The second is tasked with contesting the already rendered court decision before the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC).
This is the only way they can protect the decisions of the Commission on Academic Ethics (CAE), which confirm instances of plagiarism and result in the revocation of scientific degrees and academic positions—actions that neither the head of the National Military University in Veliko Tarnovo nor the minister have taken regarding the proven cases of plagiarism by Venelin Terziev and Daniela Vezieva—the former Minister of Economy in the previous caretaker government.
Professor Stoykov intends to send materials to the European Commission for Education and Science regarding confirmed cases of plagiarism by the CAE, in which rectors and/or the education minister refuse to comply with the law.
He again highlighted the case of Venelin Terziev, for whom the CAE proved that he obtained two of his scientific titles through plagiarism.
This is the first time such a situation has occurred in Bulgaria’s academic history and can be compared to an elephant crashing into a glass shop,” commented the professor, who is waging battles on multiple fronts against plagiarism. He awaits the results of the investigations into professors Dimitar Dimitrov and Dobri Yarkov, as well as who will dismiss them as rectors of UNSS and Trakia University in Stara Zagora.
“Za Istinata” will also monitor the development and resolution of these criminal plots.











